ConferenzaConferenza.in
Practice MCQsCA FinalDirect Tax Laws & International Taxation

Deduction, Collection & Recovery of Tax: CA Final MCQs

18 min read29 July 20260 viewsConferenza Conferenza

Deduction, collection and recovery of tax forms one of the most applied topics in CA Final Direct Tax Law — and it appears repeatedly in exams as scenario-based MCQs and short answer questions. The examiners love testing your grasp of when TDS is mandatory, who is liable, what happens when it's not done, and how tax is recovered from defaulters. This article walks through the key concepts and then hands you 18 real Conferenza MCQs that have appeared in mock exams and past papers.

Core Concepts You Must Know

Tax Deduction at Source (TDS) vs Tax Collection at Source (TCS)

TDS is mandatory deduction of income tax by the payer (deductor) from the income paid to the payee (deductee). The deductor must remit this to the government and furnish a certificate (Form 16/16A) to the payee. TDS is levied on salaries, interest, dividends, professional fees, commissions, and many other categories of income.

TCS, by contrast, is collected at source by the seller/manufacturer on specific goods (like timber, scrap, minerals, jewellery) and must be paid to the government. Failure to collect TCS exposes the collector to imprisonment — notably, under Section 276BB, the minimum imprisonment period for TCS non-payment is 3 months (a common exam trap).

When is TDS Mandatory?

TDS becomes mandatory only when:

  • The payment exceeds the prescribed threshold limit for that category of income (e.g., ₹10,000 for interest on securities).
  • The person making the payment is within the definition of "deductor" for that section (e.g., employer, bank, company, firm, cooperative, or individual/HUF whose annual turnover exceeds tax audit limits).
  • The payee is a resident of India (in most cases).

Critically, for FPS and FTS under Section 194J, an individual or HUF whose turnover does not exceed the tax audit limits is NOT required to deduct tax — this is a major relief for small practitioners and is often tested.

Who Bears the Tax Liability?

If income is liable to TDS but the deductor fails to deduct it, the primary liability to pay the tax falls on the assessee (the payee). The assessee must include that income in their return and pay the tax due. The deductor can be held accountable separately for the default, but this does not relieve the assessee of their obligation.

However, the deductor will NOT be deemed an "assessee-in-default" if the payee subsequently furnishes a return of income, includes the income, and pays the tax due, provided the payer furnishes an accountant's certificate confirming non-deduction. This is an important exception that saves the deductor from penalty in certain cases.

TDS on Salary: The Mechanics

Employers calculate TDS on salary using the rates in force for the relevant financial year, applied to the estimated total income. If an employee opts for the new tax regime (Section 115BAC), the employer must use the new regime rates. If the employee does not intimate a choice, the employer must default to Section 115BAC — this is the law post-FY 2023-24.

Employees can claim relief for losses (e.g., from house property) — but there is a cap: a loss under house property is limited to ₹2,00,000 for TDS calculation purposes. This prevents employees from using unlimited losses to avoid TDS.

When an employer pays tax on non-monetary perquisites on behalf of an employee, this tax is worked out at the average rate applicable to the employee's aggregate salary income, not the marginal rate.

TDS on Interest, Dividend, and Professional Fees

Each category of income has its own threshold and rate:

Interest on Securities (S193)₹10,000 threshold
Dividend (S194)10% rate
Non-Securities Interest (S194A)₹40,000 threshold (normal) / ₹1,00,000 (senior citizen)
FPS/FTS (S194J)10% rate
E-Commerce (S194-O)0.1% rate

Dividend on domestic companies is taxed at 10% if paid to a resident individual. However, if the dividend is paid by any mode other than cash and the aggregate does not exceed ₹10,000, TDS is not required.

Interest under Section 194A has different thresholds for different payees. For a non-senior citizen, the limit is ₹40,000 for co-operative societies engaged in banking. For a senior citizen, it rises to ₹1,00,000 — a key point that appears frequently in exams.

FPS under Section 194J explicitly covers fees for professional services rendered in advertising, accountancy, technical consultancy, and similar fields. Interestingly, sculpture, painting, and teaching are NOT explicitly covered under FPS in the section — this is a classic MCQ trap.

TDS on Recognised Provident Fund (RPF) Withdrawals

Premature withdrawal from an RPF (before statutory maturity) is treated as taxable income. If Mr X withdraws ₹55,000 after 4 years and 10 months, this is premature and TDS at 10% applies to the entire withdrawn amount (not just the portion exceeding ₹50,000). The 10% is the statutory rate; it's applied uniformly.

TDS on Advance Tax and Self-Assessment Tax

To recover income-tax during the financial year itself (before the assessment is finalized), the government allows two mechanisms: Advance Tax and Self-Assessment Tax (SAT). Advance tax is payable in four instalments if the tax liability for the year exceeds ₹10,000. Self-assessment tax can be paid at any time during the year. Both reduce the final tax demand.

Practice Questions

These 18 MCQs are drawn from Conferenza's exam-standard question bank. Work through each one carefully; they mirror the difficulty and style of the CA Final exam.

Q1. The minimum imprisonment period prescribed for failure to pay TCS to the credit of the Central Government (Section 276BB) is:

  1. 1 month.
  2. 3 months.
  3. 6 months.
  4. 1 year.
Show answer & explanation

Correct answer: B. Section 276BB prescribes a minimum imprisonment of 3 months (and up to 7 years) for willfully failing to collect or pay TCS. This stringent penalty reflects the seriousness of tax collection failures. Common error: confusing this with TDS penalties, which have different thresholds.

Q2. Fees for Professional Services (FPS) under Section 194J explicitly include services rendered in the course of carrying on the profession of:

  1. Teaching.
  2. Sculpture.
  3. Advertising.
  4. Painting.
Show answer & explanation

Correct answer: C. Section 194J covers FPS in accountancy, law, engineering, architecture, technical consultancy, and advertising. Teaching, sculpture, and painting are not explicitly listed under FPS — they fall under different heads or may be covered under technical services separately. This distinction is critical for determining who must deduct tax.

Q3. TDS on Fees for Professional Services (FPS) and Fees for Technical Services (FTS) under Section 194J is generally mandatory for any person other than:

  1. A company or a firm.
  2. An individual or HUF whose turnover exceeds the tax audit limits.
  3. An individual or HUF whose turnover does not exceed the tax audit limits.
  4. A Central or State Government department.
Show answer & explanation

Correct answer: C. Small individuals and HUFs below the tax audit turnover threshold (₹1 crore) are exempted from deducting tax under Section 194J. This is a major relief for freelancers and small service providers. The exemption applies regardless of the amount paid, as long as the overall turnover condition is satisfied.

Q4. The statutory rate of TDS under Section 194-O (TDS on e-commerce transactions) is:

  1. 0.1%.
  2. 1%.
  3. 2%.
  4. 5%.
Show answer & explanation

Correct answer: A. Section 194-O imposes a TDS of 0.1% on e-commerce operator payments to sellers. This is an extremely low rate designed to minimize friction in digital commerce while ensuring tax compliance tracking. Threshold: payments above ₹20,000 per financial year trigger this TDS.

Q5. Which of the following is considered a method for recovering income-tax from the assessee during the previous year itself?

  1. Payment of Self-Assessment Tax.
  2. Payment of Advance Tax.
  3. Payment of Assessed Tax.
  4. Payment of Wealth Tax.
Show answer & explanation

Correct answer: B. Advance tax (quarterly instalments) and self-assessment tax are the two mechanisms for collecting tax during the financial year itself, before the final assessment. This reduces the tax demand after assessment. Assessed tax is paid after assessment, and wealth tax is a different head of levy.

Q6. In the case of income for which tax is liable to be deducted at source but is not actually deducted, who is primarily liable to pay the tax?

  1. The Deductor (person responsible for paying).
  2. The Assessee (recipient of income).
  3. Both the Deductor and the Assessee, jointly.
  4. The Tax Recovery Officer.
Show answer & explanation

Correct answer: B. The assessee (payee) who received the income is primarily liable to pay the tax, even if the deductor failed to deduct it. The assessee must include the income in their return and discharge the tax obligation. The deductor faces separate liability for non-deduction, but this does not shift the assessee's primary responsibility.

Q7. A person required to deduct tax at source fails to do so. Under which condition will this person NOT be deemed an "assessee-in-default"?

  1. If the assessee (payee) subsequently pays the tax through self-assessment tax.
  2. If the assessee (payee) furnishes a return of income and pays the tax due on the included income, and the payer furnishes an accountant's certificate.
  3. If the amount involved is below the threshold limit prescribed under the relevant TDS section.
  4. If the delay in deduction is less than 30 days and the deductor provides a valid reason.
Show answer & explanation

Correct answer: B. The deductor is protected from being treated as assessee-in-default if: (1) the payee includes the income in their return, (2) the payee pays the tax due, and (3) the deductor furnishes a certificate from a CA confirming non-deduction. This exception incentivises transparency and cooperation between parties.

Q8. TDS on salary is to be calculated by the employer on the estimated total income based on the average rate of income-tax. The average rate is calculated on the basis of:

  1. The maximum marginal rate of tax applicable in the relevant financial year.
  2. The rates in force for the relevant financial year.
  3. The standard rate of 10% applicable to all salaried individuals.
  4. The slab rates applicable in the immediately preceding assessment year.
Show answer & explanation

Correct answer: B. The average rate for TDS on salary must be calculated using the rates in force for the current financial year, not the preceding year. This ensures TDS reflects current tax slabs and rebates. If the employee opts for the new regime, the new regime rates apply; otherwise, Section 115BAC rates are the default.

Q9. When an employee does not intimate their intended tax regime to the employer, the employer is generally mandated to deduct tax at source using the rates specified under:

  1. The most beneficial tax regime for the employee (old regime).
  2. The default tax regime (Section 115BAC).
  3. The slab rates as if the individual were a senior citizen.
  4. The maximum marginal rate of tax (30% plus surcharge/cess).
Show answer & explanation

Correct answer: B. Post-FY 2023-24, if the employee does not communicate their tax regime choice, the employer must apply Section 115BAC (new regime) rates. This is the statutory default. The employee can later file their return under the old regime if they wish, but TDS will have been deducted at the new regime rate.

Q10. An employer opts to pay the tax liability on non-monetary perquisites provided to the employee. This tax must be worked out at:

  1. The marginal rate applicable to the employee's highest income slab.
  2. The average rate applicable to the aggregate salary income of the employee.
  3. A flat rate of 10% on the value of the non-monetary perquisites.
  4. A special fixed rate of 20% as per perquisite rules.
Show answer & explanation

Correct answer: B. When an employer pays tax on behalf of an employee on non-monetary perquisites (e.g., housing, club membership), the tax is calculated at the average rate of tax on the employee's total income, including the perquisite. This avoids the distortion of applying the marginal rate, which would be inequitable.

Q11. An individual employee informs their employer about a loss under the head 'Income from house property' to reduce their TDS on salary. The maximum limit for this loss that the employer can take into account while calculating TDS is:

  1. Unlimited, provided proper evidence is furnished.
  2. ₹ 1,50,000.
  3. ₹ 2,00,000.
  4. Only the amount of interest on borrowed capital, restricted to ₹ 2,00,000.
Show answer & explanation

Correct answer: C. The loss from house property that an employee can claim for TDS reduction is capped at ₹2,00,000 per financial year. This limit prevents employees from using disproportionate property losses to eliminate TDS on salary. The loss claimed must be substantiated by documentary evidence.

Q12. Mr. X withdraws ₹ 55,000 from his Recognized Provident Fund (RPF) account after 4 years and 10 months of continuous service. What is the TDS rate applicable on this premature taxable withdrawal?

  1. Nil, as the withdrawal amount is less than ₹ 1,00,000.
  2. 10% on the entire withdrawn amount.
  3. 20% on the amount exceeding ₹ 50,000.
  4. Tax is to be computed as if it were an unrecognised provident fund.
Show answer & explanation

Correct answer: B. Premature withdrawal from an RPF (before 5 years or before specified conditions are met) triggers TDS at 10% on the entire taxable amount, regardless of the quantum. The 10% rate is statutory and applies uniformly. It is not a tiered rate based on the amount.

Q13. TDS on 'Interest on Securities' (Section 193) is applicable only if the aggregate amount of interest paid or credited during the financial year to a resident exceeds:

  1. ₹ 5,000.
  2. ₹ 10,000.
  3. ₹ 20,000.
  4. ₹ 50,000.
Show answer & explanation

Correct answer: B. Section 193 TDS on interest from government securities, bonds, and debentures applies only if the aggregate interest in a financial year exceeds ₹10,000 for a resident individual. Below this threshold, no TDS is required. This is a critical threshold to remember for bond and securities investments.

Q14. The statutory rate of TDS on dividend income distributed or paid by a domestic company to a resident shareholder is:

  1. 2%.
  2. 5%.
  3. 10%.
  4. 20%.
Show answer & explanation

Correct answer: C. Under Section 194, dividend paid by an Indian company to a resident individual or HUF is subject to TDS at 10%. This rate has been consistent for several years. Note: Dividend distribution tax (DDT) on companies was abolished from April 1, 2020, so TDS at the shareholder level is now the primary collection mechanism.

Q15. TDS on Dividend (Section 194) is NOT required to be made in the case of a shareholder (being an individual) if:

  1. The dividend is paid in cash, and the aggregate amount does not exceed ₹ 10,000.
  2. The dividend is paid by any mode other than cash, and the aggregate amount does not exceed ₹ 10,000.
  3. The dividend is paid to a senior citizen regardless of the amount.
  4. The dividend income is exempt under Section 10.
Show answer & explanation

Correct answer: B. TDS on dividend is not required if the dividend is paid by a mode other than cash (e.g., cheque, transfer, NECS) and the aggregate amount does not exceed ₹10,000 in a financial year. If paid in cash, TDS is always required. This exception applies only to non-cash mode payments.

Q16. A Hindu Undivided Family (HUF) whose total sales from business were ₹ 95 lakhs in the immediately preceding financial year is responsible for deducting tax under Section 194A on interest (other than on securities) only if:

  1. The interest is paid to a senior citizen.
  2. The HUF is registered under the GST Act.
  3. The HUF's turnover exceeds ₹ 1 crore.
  4. The interest exceeds the specified threshold limit.
Show answer & explanation

Correct answer: C. An HUF or individual is required to deduct tax under Section 194A only if their turnover in the immediately preceding financial year exceeds ₹1 crore. Here, the HUF's sales were ₹95 lakhs, so no TDS obligation arises on interest payments, regardless of the interest amount. This turnover criterion is the primary gate-keeper for this TDS section.

Q17. Mr. B, a non-senior citizen, has FD interest of ₹ 45,000 from a co-operative society engaged in banking business. The TDS limit for this interest is:

  1. ₹ 10,000.
  2. ₹ 40,000.
  3. ₹ 50,000.
  4. ₹ 1,00,000.
Show answer & explanation

Correct answer: C. Under Section 194A, for a non-senior citizen, the threshold limit for TDS on interest from a co-operative society engaged in banking is ₹50,000 (note: different from banks at ₹40,000). Since Mr. B's interest is ₹45,000, it falls below the limit; TDS is not required. The distinction between bank and cooperative rates is important for precision.

Q18. For a senior citizen, the threshold limit for non-deduction of TDS on interest from a banking company, co-operative society engaged in banking business, or post office (for notified schemes) is:

  1. ₹ 50,000.
  2. ₹ 75,000.
  3. ₹ 1,00,000.
  4. ₹ 2,00,000.
Show answer & explanation

Correct answer: C. Senior citizens enjoy a much higher TDS-free threshold: ₹1,00,000 on interest from banks, cooperatives engaged in banking, and notified post office schemes under Section 194A. This is an important relief mechanism recognizing the income needs of retired individuals. The threshold is double or more than that for non-senior citizens.

You can practise thousands more free and paid MCQs on the Conferenza app — download it today to test yourself on random question sets and track your progress across all CA Final subjects.

Expert Tips for Exam Success

  • Memorise the thresholds: Each TDS section has a specific threshold (₹10,000 for securities interest, ₹40,000–₹1,00,000 for non-securities interest depending on payer and payee, etc.). Create a one-page reference table and test yourself weekly.
  • Distinguish between payer categories: A company must always deduct; an individual or HUF below ₹1 crore turnover is exempt from many TDS sections. This distinction cascades through multiple sections and is frequently tested.
  • Read conditions carefully: Many MCQs hinge on fine language — "any mode other than cash", "in the immediately preceding financial year", "aggregate amount". Do not rush.
  • Link TDS to return filing: Understand that TDS is a provisional payment; the final tax is assessed after the assessee files their return. This relationship clarifies who is liable when deduction is missed.
  • Refer to the latest ICAI Standards and Notifications: TDS rates, thresholds, and exemptions are amended frequently via Budget announcements and CBIC/Tax Board circulars. Before your exam, verify the current figures with the official ICAI syllabus and any recent updates published on the Income Tax Department website.

Recommended Study Resources

To deepen your understanding of this chapter, consider enrolling in focused lectures. All courses by Bhanwar Borana are highly regarded for their clarity and exam-focus. For comprehensive coverage, you may also explore:

For quick reference while revising, grab the CA/CMA Final Compact A Handwritten Notes on Direct Tax New Scheme By CA Bhanwar Borana Applicable For Nov/Dec 26 Exams — ₹720. These notes are concise, hand-written for clarity, and aligned with the latest scheme.

FAQs

Q: What is the difference between "assessee-in-default" and simply failing to deduct TDS?
A: Every person required to deduct TDS becomes an "assessee-in-default" if they fail to deduct. However, there is an exception: if the payee files a return, includes the income, and pays the tax, and the payer furnishes a CA's certificate, the payer is not deemed in default. This exception protects deductors who have acted in good faith and ensures the revenue is collected even if deduction was missed.

Q: Can an employee claim unlimited losses from house property to reduce TDS on salary?
A: No. The loss from house property that can be set off against salary for TDS purposes is capped at ₹2,00,000 per financial year. This is a statutory limit to prevent employees from avoiding TDS through disproportionate property losses. The loss must also be substantiated.

Q: Why is the TDS rate on e-commerce transactions (Section 194-O) so low at 0.1%?
A: The ultra-low rate of 0.1% is a policy choice to encourage digital commerce and reduce compliance friction, whilst still ensuring a revenue trail for tax authorities. The low rate reflects the government's push for digital transactions and broader taxation coverage through a lighter touch on e-commerce platforms.

Q: Are senior citizens completely exempt from TDS on interest income?
A: No. Senior citizens are granted higher thresholds (₹1,00,000 instead of ₹40,000–₹50,000), not complete exemption. They must still file returns and declare interest income above the threshold. The higher limit is a concession recognizing their fixed-income status and lower earning capacity post-retirement.

Final Word

Master the thresholds, commit the rates to memory, and practise applying them to real-world scenarios. Deduction, collection and recovery of tax is one chapter where precision and accuracy matter far more than conceptual depth — every rupee and every day matters in the eyes of the tax officer. Work through these 18 MCQs repeatedly, and you'll develop the exam instinct this topic demands. Best of luck, and start with a budget-friendly lecture series to consolidate your fundamentals today.

#TDS#tax deduction at source#CA Final direct tax#Section 194J#tax recovery#assessee-in-default
Share this articleWhatsApp𝕏XinLinkedIn

Explore Bhanwar Borana's courses on Conferenza

Video lectures, books and thousands of free practice MCQs for CA, CS & CMA — all in one place.

View coursesExplore books
← Back to all articles